Essays On The American Dream And The Crucible


1. Introduction
1.1. The coming about of The Crucible
1.2. Puritanism - Puritan

2. The Puritan World in The Crucible
2.1 Church Services
2.2 The Bible
2.3 Believe in the Devil and his servants
2.4 Everybody can be a target
2.5 Women and their link to the devil
2.6 Oppression of personal feelings and freedom
2.7 Clergy and Judges
2.8 Confession

3. Conclusion


1. Introduction

“With belief in witchcraft almost universal in Europe and America in the seventeenth century, the New England Puritans had no need to invent a theory of demonology. But as Puritans they applied such notions with a vigour and persistence unrivalled among their fellow colonists. Only in New England did persecution of witches assume epidemic proportions; only there did people die for consorting with Satan. The precise reasons for the outbreaks in Connecticut and Massachusetts remain obscure, but there seems little doubt that a casual connection obtained between the hyper-religiosity of the Puritan mind and the rooting out of the devil’s agent […]” (Vaughan 276)

What happened in Salem, in 1692, is today described as one of the darkest episodes in American history. Still today, historians try to find out what caused the disastrous outbreak of the witch craze but the only thing they can be sure about is that they can not explain why so many people had to die. (Breslaw 104) “Accusations of witchcraft were not unusual in the seventeenth-century world […]” (Breslaw 103) What was so special about the time and place that such an outbreak of random accusations became possible? “[…] “Salem” has become an icon in American culture. The trials have become a metaphor for hysterical prosecution, unfounded accusations, and confessions that have no reasonable explanation.” (Reis 10) Believe in witchcraft had existed for hundreds of years before the hysteria broke out in Salem. The colonists who came to Massachusetts had a strong belief in the devil and his agents and were mainly Puritans, who came to America to gain religious freedom. (Langston 8)

There are many things you could compare between the historical account of the witch hunt and Arthur Miller’s play The Crucible. This paper is going to analyse the portrayal of a Puritan society in Miller’s play and will try to find out whether the religion of the people and therewith their way of life have caused the rising of the witch scare and the horrible outcome for the characters in the play. It is going to be analysed why normal people start accusing their neighbours and friends for witchcraft although many of them are aware of the consequences for the accused.

At first it is going to be described how Arthur Miller informed himself about the happenings of 1692 in order to underline his credibility of being able to create the Puritan society of that time. In the following the terms ‘Puritanism’ and ‘Puritan’ will be briefly defined. The main part of the paper will concentrate on the analysis of Puritan traits, beliefs, and lifestyles in The Crucible in order to find out whether they might have played a part in the catastrophe.

1.1. The coming about of The Crucible

Arthur Miller did a lot of research on the topic before he started writing his play in 1952. (Gottfried 214) He visited Salem to see everything for himself and had a look at the documents from 1692 in Salem courthouse. The documents told him what happened to the people of that time and he learned a lot about the procedures of the court. (Martin, Centola 27) In his book The Crucible in history Miller wrote that “one of [his] most useful sources was the 1867 two-volume history of the trials by Charles W. Upham, who had been Mayor of Salem, albeit nearly a century and a half after the catastrophe” (Miller, 2000, 48) In a ‘Note on the historical accuracy of the play’ Arthur Miller himself admitted that his work is not entirely historical and the documents which describe the goings-on of 1692 can easily prove that the author changed a number of things in order to make them fit in his drama. (Miller, 2002, 1975) Miller reduced the settings to one place for each act and he also limited the number of characters to the most important ones, fusing many of them into one. You can also see in the documents that the whole incident did not happen in such a short period of time. In fact a timeline of the happenings shows that it all started in January 1692 and only ended a year later. (Fremon appendix) Despite the fact that Miller had to change some things to arrange his drama he still takes the reader into a time of deep religious believers and captures the essence of it, portraying the Puritan society of 1692 Salem.

1.2. Puritanism - Puritan

The American Puritanism had its origins in England and developed in the second half of the seventeenth century. There were many people who wanted to change the English church. (Vaughan 1) The Puritan movement emerged quickly and soon they were not welcome in England anymore because they thought the changes that were made in England were not enough and they wanted the church to change further. (Vaughan 35) In seek of refuge they travelled to New England, America, and founded Plymouth plantation, which was the beginning of the Puritan tradition in America. (Vaughan 41) Puritanism is said to be an amorphous, multifaceted, and dynamic movement and any broad definition seems to be inadequate. (Vaughan xi) The people who came to New England brought their cultural English background with them and their religious commitment can be called a radically reformed Protestantism. (Vaughan xii) Their culture but also their religion was reshaped in America in many ways. They founded a special “New England Way of life”. (Vaughan xii)

“[…] New England Puritans established an experiment in Christian living that reconstructed not only church policy and procedures but most of society’s institutions and everyday practices. […] The central Puritan religious experience—the soul’s conversion or rebirth—required adherents to reform their lives. Puritanism asked them to look with new eyes at the nature and structure of government, at the role of communities, at the obligations of families; to have new attitudes toward work, toward leisure, toward witches and the wonders of the world.” (Vaughan xiii)

Being a Puritan therefore affected every moment of a person’s existence. The religion was essential not only for private life but it also affected the life of the community; it affected politics and also the economy.

The Oxford English Dictionary defines a Puritan as “[a] member of that party of English Protestants who regarded the reformation of the church under Elizabeth as incomplete, and called for its further purification from what they considered to be unscriptural and corrupt forms and ceremonies retained from the unreformed church” (Murray 1621) The term is also used to describe people who are “[…] extremely strict, precise, or scrupulous in religion or morals.” (Murray 1621)

2. The Puritan World in The Crucible

In the beginning of the play Miller gives a brief account of the situation in Salem right before the outbreak of the witch hunt. He mentions that many Europeans saw the New Colonies as a group of fanatics who led a strict and somber life. He also notes that people had a preference of minding everybody’s business. (Miller, 2002, 1976) The characters in his play are a very dedicated folk and live in a communal society joint by a religious ideology. They believe that they can only be safe if they stick together and live in good organized Christian community. They are afraid of everything different and believe that the devil is living in the woods that surround Salem village. On top of that the people also live in a time of change where some of them try to become more independent from the community and start to think about their own life and their success first. The people of Salem have developed a theocracy that combines religion and state. This combination of power which is built on the idea of exclusion and prohibition is supposed to hold them all together and to protect them from material or ideological enemies. (Miller, 2002, 1977) The witch hunt and the harsh reaction to the witch craze is the effect of a society that is starting to get out of balance in their turn toward greater personal freedom. But out of the oppression of personal freedom comes the accusation of witch craft. They have had to oppress personal feelings for such a long time that some characters use the opportunity for revenge. (Miller, 2002, 1978) “Old scares could be settled on a plane of heavenly combat between Lucifer and the Lord […]” (Miller, 2002, 1978)


The "Falseness" Of The American Dream In Arthur Miller's Writing

Many associate the American Dream with the years following World War II. One sees the 1950's as movies and books portray them; a happy-go-lucky time where every household has two-point-five children, a dog, and a picket fence around their house. Many families strive and work all their lives to fulfill their American Dream, but when reality sets in, they end up failing and their American Dream turns into a nightmare: the American Reality. The origins of the American Dream seem to have been rooted in the pioneering mentality of the 18th and 19th century immigrants, most of who came to America because of a promise of a new and better life. In particular, one came to America to own land of their own. But land 'ran out' and cities developed and financial situations changed quickly, meaning that this 'American Dream' changed from being a potential reality, into being a dream, like the name implies. Most of Miller's plays are directly or indirectly about the American Dream, conveying his opinion that ultimately this dream was not going to succeed as many wished it would. Arthur Miller's plays All My Sons and A View from the Bridge use situations to show the "falseness" and disintegration of the American Dream in post-World War II times.

The disintegration of the American Dream after World War II is portrayed by Arthur Miller in A View from the Bridge when families turn on each other to protect themselves. Eddie, like Joe in All My Sons, believes that achieving the American Dreamis being successful financial and protecting one's family. Eddie believes that his wife's cousins who are living with him, illegal immigrant from Italy, are a threat to his niece,Catherine, and attempts to remove them from his life. The turning point of the play is when Eddie reports Marco and Rodolfo to the police. "I'm just around the neighborhood, that's all" (66, A View from the Bridge, Arthur Miller). Eddie makes the police think he is just a random neighbor of the immigrants, when in truth he is turning in his own family. Eddie turning in his own family to immigration shows how the American Dream is false, because no matter what one tries to do, they may not succeed in America because of matters out of their hands. Rodolfo tends to be pessimistic and "is inclined to remember the ruin in things, perhaps because [he] was born in Italy" (26, Miller). Rodolfo has a negative outlook on his old county, but he views America as a place of the American Dream which will let him lead a wonderful life free of ruin. Miller also shows his disillusionment in the American Dream by having Eddie look down upon society. Eddie tells his nice "Just remember, kid, you can quicker get back a million dollars that was stole than a word you gave away" (18, Miller). Eddie believes that in America one must keep his wits about him and never say anything one...

Loading: Checking Spelling


Read more

"Willy Loman's Idealistic American Dream and the Victimization that Ensues"... in Arthur Miller's "Death of a Salesman"

985 words - 4 pages Who does not want to live the perfect life, the American Dream? Throughout Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman, Willy Loman is...

Arthur Miller's Purpose for Writing The Crucible

895 words - 4 pages Parallels between Arthur Miller’s play, The Crucible, and his article Why I wrote the Crucible, can easily support Miller’s reasons for writing this classic play. Miller’s purpose in writing both the play and the article was to emphasize the similarities between the 1692 witch hunt and the 1950’s Red Scare. Miller simply wanted to convey the message of fear over reason, express himself in a new language of old English, to warn of mass hysteria,...

Mythical American Dream Challenged in Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman

988 words - 4 pages Mythical American Dream Challenged in Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman      Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman challenges the American dream. Before the Depression, an optimistic America offered the alluring promise of success and riches. Willy Loman suffers from his disenchantment with the American dream, for it fails him and his son. In some ways, Willy and Biff seem trapped in a transitional period of American history. Willy, now...

Death of a Salesman by Arthur Miller, uses textual references to show Miller's opinion that the American dream is difficult or impossible in today's capitalistic society.

922 words - 4 pages In today's capitalist economy, many strive for the same goal and while some are met with success, most are left with nothing but shattered dreams and low wages. Arthur Miller wrote his play "Death of a Salesman" as a satire on the American Dream and what he saw as the futile pursuit and false ideals that accompanied the dream. Through

Important Writing Elements Used in Arthur Miller's Play, Death of a Salesman

786 words - 3 pages In the play Death of a Salesman, Arthur Miller uses an old style of reality that deals with emotional and financial struggles. These struggles are viewed throughout the whole play. The play was written around the 1940s, which was around the time of the Great Depression. This was a very difficult time in which a lot of people struggled just like the Loman family did in the play. Arthur Miller uses several elements in the play which are:...

The Presence of Pride in Arthur Miller's The Crucible

671 words - 3 pages The Presence of Pride in Arthur Miller's "The Crucible"In Miller's "The Crucible" the pride of the people of Salem leads to a massacre of innocent lives. Pride is delight or elation arising from some act, possession, or relationship. One of the main characters, John Proctor, has pride in his beliefs of purifying the Church of England. His wife, Elizabeth, has...

The Role of Vengeance in Arthur Miller's The Crucible

1201 words - 5 pages Throughout the endurance of Arthur Miller's The Crucible, vengeance plays a prominent role in the actions and fates of various characters. In many ways, vengeance fuels the need for retaliation. Disputes among neighbors has bred hatred and then witch trials brought out the vindictiveness of Salem's population. This leads to the deaths of many citizens in Salem by false accusations to the court. Citizens of Salem were utilizing the court system as...

The Failure of the American Dream in "Death of a Salesman" by Arthur Miller.

1207 words - 5 pages All people -- from millionaires with mansions living on the hilltops to the poor and unhealthy bums living on the streets -- have one goal: to reach their fullest ability, or achieve their American Dream. The above examples are the extremes of an American system in which wealth and status decide your friends, future, and well-being. Personally, I think the American Dream is to attain the status that you desire -- whether it is social...

In what ways does Arthur Miller present the failure of the American Dream?

1473 words - 6 pages Arthur Miller's main character is a failure: Willy Loman is eventually worth more dead than alive, and 'nobody's worth nothing dead'. All his life, he strives for the American dream - a good career, a loving wife, a...

Marriage of John and Elizabeth in Arthur Miller's The Crucible

1020 words - 4 pages Marriage of John and Elizabeth in Arthur Miller's The Crucible John Proctor shows many strengths and weaknesses throughout The Crucible. He is honest, upright and blunt-spoken. His manliness acts a great strength, but also as a weakness, for this is what led him to his affair with Abigail. The guilt he feels over this contributes to his imprisonment and death as it prevents him from speaking out soon enough. ...

Character Study of Abigail Williams in Arthur Miller's The Crucible

1946 words - 8 pages Character Study of Abigail From Arthur Miller's The Crucible Arthur Miller was inspired to write The Crucible because of what happened in America in the 1950's. Suspicion of witchcraft and an association with the Devil had arisen in the 1600s in Salem, Massachsetts. The allegations and apprehension is comparable with the period of...

Categories: 1

0 Replies to “Essays On The American Dream And The Crucible”

Leave a comment

L'indirizzo email non verrà pubblicato. I campi obbligatori sono contrassegnati *